Narrative
Full Description
Project narrative
In 2011, China Telecom issued a loan to Axin Limited — a joint venture and special purpose vehicle (SPV) — that accounted for approximately half of the funding for the $8.5 million NZD Auckland-Whangarei Submarine Internet Cable Project. Axin Limited (Axin Ltd.), is a SPV of Shanghai Communication Services (a subsidiary of state-owned China Telecom) that was established in 2010. In 2011, New Zealand’s Companies Office listed Axin Ltd. as being half owned by Sino Telecom (NZ) Limited, whose two shareholders were Robin Lee and Fei Ling, both of Mt Eden, Auckland. Counties Power, a New Zealand electric distributor, was a joint venture partner on Axin before dropping out by September 2011. Axin had an exclusive contract to represent Shanghai Communications Services in New Zealand. The purpose of the project was to construct a 200 kilometer, Māori-owned submarine internet cable (fibre-optic network) connecting Auckland and Whangarei, enabling high-speed Internet connections to the region. The network was said to have speeds between 100 megabits per second (1Mbit/s) and 1 gigabit per second (Gibit/s) (1000Mbit/s), no data caps, no core network complexities, point-to-point fibre configurations, private networking capacity, and high fiber count. This was the first iwi-owned long-haul network in New Zealand. The network is owned by Taitokerau Networks, a limited partnership between six iwi (Te Runanga o Whaingaroa, Te Runanga o Ngati Whatua and Te Runanga o Te Rarawa) and Datalight Limited. Taitokerau Networks provided the other half of the financing for this project. New Zealand companies FX Networks and Datalight were the contractors responsible for the design, construction, and sale of the network; specifically, FX Network was in charge of the design, construction, and dark fiber (whole bandwith) sales, while Datalight was the project manager and responsible for the design and construction of layer two (retail or lit fiber) services. China Telecom supplied materials and provided logistical support for the project. Axin also provided materials for the project. China Telecom was not the first choice for sourcing funds for the project. Taitokerau Networks had attempted to garner funding from New Zealand investors, but they had wanted an equity stake in the project, making the project no longer iwi-owned. Te Runanga o Te Rarawa chairman Haami Piripi was quoted by NBR that ‘the irony is not lost on us’ that a Chinese state-owned company provided financing after New Zealand's Finance and Infrastructure Minister Bill English declined to provide New Zealand government funding for the project. Additionally, the project faced some criticism for the fact that the cable ran up the west coast of Tai Tokerau and east of where most of the people and money were, although its supporters argued that the intentions of the project were to connect to the isolated Māori communities in the north and not make a large profit. The project was originally intended to begin implementation in March 2011 and to reach completion five months later (August 2012). Construction began in the middle of September 2011. In December 2011, the project was briefly marred by an alleged ‘procedural glitch’ briefly interrupted project implementation, as a payment from China Telecom failed to reach the accounts of one contractor. Project officials blamed a glitch relating to a shift in payment for payments from Axin to CCS Comservice NZ, a company owned by China Telecom's international arm China Communications Services. After the payment was received, work resumed on the project. As of December 2011, the project had achieved a 70% completion rate. The project was ultimately completed on or around May 10, 2012.
Staff comments
1. This project is also known as the Auckland-Whangarei Fibre Optic Cable Project, the Northern Network Broadband Project, and Stage One of the Northern Broadband Project. 2. This project was envisioned as the first phase of a $30 million NZD project to expand broadband access across New Zealand, with new connections to the Bay of Islands, Kaeo, Kaitaia, Hokianga and Dargaville for stage two and a western route from Auckland to Whangarei and Kaitaia to Waitiki Landing for stage three to be constructed. The Auckland-Whangarei Submarine Internet Cable Project was expected to subsidize the second stage of the wider project (see "Iwi celebrate stage one of northern broadband project" and "Iwi broadband deal on way"). 3. It is possible that the borrowing institution was not Axin Limited but Axin New Zealand Limited (or Axin NZ), which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Sino Telecom (NZ) Limited (see "3404512 AXIN NEW ZEALAND LIMITED - April 28, 2014"). Sino Telecom (NZ) Limited is a wholly owned subsidiary of China Telecom (a Chinese state-owned telecommunications company). Axin New Zealand Limited was legally incorporated on June 21, 2011 (see "AXIN NEW ZEALAND LIMITED NZBN: 9429031076463"). Axin Limited was legally incorporated on September 14, 2010. This issue warrants further investigation. 4. One source ("Iwi broadband deal on way") indicates that "Financing will come equally from iwi and from China through Axin NZ, with iwi retaining ownership of the network." Therefore, AidData assumes that the face value of the loan from China Telecom was worth $4.25 million NZD, as this is half of the project cost of $8.5 million NZD. 5. The address of Axin New Zealand Limited (or Axin NZ) from June 21, 2011 to September 28, 2011 was 34 Maui Grove, Remuera, Auckland, NZ 1050. From September 28, 2011 to August 1, 2012, it was Corner Sh22 And Heights Road, Paerata, Pukekohe, NZ 2676. From August 1, 2012 to present, the address is 58 Taylor Road, Rd 4, Pukekohe, NZ 2679 (see "3404512 AXIN NEW ZEALAND LIMITED - April 28, 2014"). 6. Several sources ("Chinese bankroll Maori fibre-optic plans" and "Iwi broadband deal on way") describe the length of the fiber-optic network between Auckland and Whangarei as 165 kilometers, not 200 kilometers. This discrepancy warrants additional investigation.