Narrative
Full Description
Project narrative
On May 11, 2018, China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (Sinosure) and the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq signed an export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement (contract ID# FA-IRAQ-001). Under the terms of the 20-year agreement, the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq is authorized to borrow up to $10 billion (or an equivalent amount in other currencies such as RMB) via subsidiary buyer’s credit facility agreements with PRC banks and/or commercial contracts with deferred payment clauses (i.e. supplier’s credits) with Chinese companies (exporters) for projects in the ‘oil, gas, energy, infrastructure, communications, education, healthcare or electricity sectors’ that are ‘located in the areas in Iraq deemed safe by the Embassy of China and the Government of Iraq.’ All borrowings under the framework agreement, which is captured via Record ID#95982, must carry maturity lengths that do not exceed 15 years and they must be backed by an approved credit insurance policy from Sinosure. The framework agreement also specifies that the Government of Iraq is responsible for making advance payments worth no less than 15% of the total cost of the underlying commercial contracts supported by the subsidiary buyer’s credits and supplier’s credits. To repay and secure these borrowings, the framework agreement specified that a Crude Oil Sales Agreement would be put in place between Iraq's state-owned oil marketing company (SOMO or شركة تسويق النفط) and one or more Chinese state-owned oil importers, wherein SOMO would agree to sell no fewer than 100,000 barrels of crude oil per day to one or more Chinese state-owned oil importers. Ultimately, SOMO agreed to sell no fewer than 100,000 barrels of crude oil per day to ZhenHua Oil Company and Sinochem (split equally between the two Chinese state-owned oil importers). Per the terms of the framework agreement, ZhenHua Oil Company and Sinochem agreed to make payments to SOMO due under the Crude Oil Sales Agreement by depositing U.S. dollars (or another foreign currency) in a Sinosure-designated and lender-controlled bank (escrow) account (that was opened on behalf of the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq to facilitate debt service payments). ZhenHua Oil Company and Sinochem can resell the oil, but they must transfer 65% of the resale profits to SOMO. They can retain 35% of the resale profits. If resale results in a loss, the Chinese state-owned oil importer bears 100% of that loss. Under the terms of the framework agreement, the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq is required to maintain a minimum cash balance of $100 million in a Debt Service Reserve Account (DSRA) and pledge the DSRA in favor of Sinosure. Apart from the DSRA, the framework agreement refers to two additional escrow accounts: an Oil Settlement Account and a Repayment Account. All oil sale proceeds first flow to the Oil Settlement Account, which is a Central Bank of Iraq (CBI) account at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRB NY). [Note: The Oil Settlement Account is also known as the Development Fund for Iraq (DFI) Account, the Oil Proceeds Receipt Account (OPRA), the Iraq 2 Account, the Oil and Gas Revenues Account (OGRA), and the DFI Successor Account.] Then, after deductions are made from the Oil Settlement Account by the United Nations Compensation Commission for compensation due to Kuwait, the remaining revenue flows to the Repayment Account (so long as there is still a $100 million minimum cash balance in the DSRA) and principal and interest payments to lenders are made from the Repayment Account. The Government of Iraq has disclosed via EITI that that the DSRA and the Repayment Account are sources of collateral. On September 23, 2019, account agreement and oil agreement annexes to the framework agreement were finalized. Then, on September 23, 2019, the framework agreement officially went into effect. Approximately 15 months later, in December 2020, a Financial Advisor to Iraq’s Prime Minister, Dr. Mudhar Muhammad Salih, told the Iraqi News Agency (INA), that Iraq’s House of Representatives would need to identify the specific projects to be funded under the framework agreement and allocate funds for these projects in the Federal Budget Law. Then, on April 8, 2021, the Government of Iraq issued the 2021 Fiscal Year Federal Budget Law. Included in the budget was a pronouncement that $1.803 billion from the $10 billion oil-backed loan framework agreement between the Ministry of Finance and Sinosure would be used to fund infrastructure projects. Five months later, in November 2021, Salih told a local newspaper that several Chinese companies had deposited $1.8 billion in an account and the funds would be used to support these projects. This announcement implies that the Government of Iraq ultimately decided to borrowed via commercial contracts with deferred payment clauses (i.e. supplier’s credits) with Chinese companies rather than buyer’s credit facilities with PRC banks. On June 30, 2022, Dr. Mudhar Muhammad Salih said that ‘[t]he operations of depositing money and withdrawing from the [escrow] account are continuing for the benefit of the projects concluded within the [export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement with Sinosure].’ He also noted that ‘the [escrow] account is managed very carefully by the Central Bank of Iraq, and the financial operations are audited by the major international financial auditing companies.’ In 2022, SOMO also agreed to increase its sale of crude oil to ZhenHua Oil Company and Sinochem from 100,000 to 150,0000 barrels per day. It did so ‘to meet the estimated annual revenue based on the Official Selling Price (OSP) applied to all buyers (without discounts or installment payments).’ One of the projects financed under the export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement with Sinosure is the 1260MW Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant Construction Project. In September 2013, China Machinery Engineering Corporation (CMEC) and the Ministry of Electricity of Iraq signed a $1,189,132,251 commercial (EPC) contract for the 1260MW Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant Construction Project. This contract was amended on November 21, 2019 and its monetary value was increase by $140 million (to ~$1,329,132,251) after CMEC and the Government of Iraq signed a financing memorandum on September 22, 2019. The estimated monetary value of the supplier’s credit for the 1260MW Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant Construction Project is $1,129,762,413.35 (as captured via Record ID#95996). The purpose of the project was to construct an oil-fired thermal power plant that consists of two subcritical, oil-fired generating units of 630MW capacity each (‘Unit 1’ and ‘Unit 2’). Upon completion, each unit was expected consist of a boiler drum along with a boiler furnace equipped with oil and gas nozzles, and a single shaft steam turbine. The boiler assembly was expected to feature four-corner tangential combustion chamber, along with single-hearth balanced ventilation supported by steel structure frame. The design boiler maximum continuous rating (BMCR) was expected to be 2136t/h. Each double back pressure, impulse type steam turbine would feature three cylinders and four exhausts. The other major components of the plant would include three-stage high pressure heaters, four- stage low pressure heaters, eight-stage regenerative deaerators, apart from steam-driven feedwater pumps. The project also included four 20,000m3 oil mixing tanks, air compressors, as well as the construction of 400kV and 132kV booster stations. The electricity generated by the power project was to be evacuated through a 400kV power transmission line connecting the national grid of Iraq. The power plant is located approximately 16 km southeast of the Samara city in Salah Al-din Province on the north bank of the Tigris River (and approximately 186 km north of Baghdad). CMEC was the general EPC contractor responsible for project implementation. However, Northwest Research Institute of Energy China, SGS, the Fourth Construction of China Machinery Industry Co., Ltd., China Valves Technology, Inc. and Sichuan Railway Investment Group Co., Ltd. were also involved in implementation as subcontractors. Project implementation officially commenced on August 14, 2012. However, civil construction works did not begin until April 2013. The project was originally expected to reach completion within 45 months (January 2017). Construction works were suspended in June 2014 due to the fact that Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIS) launched a major attack in northern Iraq against the Iraqi government, which led to a major deterioration in the local security situation. Construction works resumed in mid-2018. As of August 2019, 1200 Chinese and Iraqi workers were assigned to the project. Then, on November 21, 2019, the Ministry of Electricity of Iraq (MOELC) and China Machinery Engineering Corporation (CMEC) signed an expanded and amended EPC contract, which allocated $140 million of additional funding for additional repair and inspection work and the construction of a new 132kV substation. On April 1, 2020, Zhang Tao, the Chinese Ambassador to Iraq, and a team from the Red Cross Society of China visited the power plant and provided on-site Covid-19 pandemic prevention and control guidance. Fifteen days later. On April 16, 2020, the boiler hydraulic test for Unit 1 took place, marking an important milestone of the project. Unit 1 began trial operations on June 2, 2021. However in late-June 2021, ISIS launched a set of targeted by Katyusha rockets at the Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant and severely damaged parts of Unit 1. The Unit 1 boiler was ignited on May 11 , 2022, and it was connected to the grid on May 12, 2022. Unit 1 then began a 720-hour reliability test on May 20, 2022. On June 19, 2022, Unit 1 passed the 720-hour reliability test. CMEC then handed over Unit 1 to the project owner in July 2022, which marked halfway point of the implementation of the project. On August 27, 2022, Unit 2 was connected to the national grid for the first time and officially put into operation. The power plant was officially commissioned on November 21, 2022.
Staff comments
1. The export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement (contract ID# FA-IRAQ-001) can be accessed in its entirety via https://www.dropbox.com/s/i0en9znldd5g59h/Sinosure%20and%20Iraq%20MOF%20Cooperation%20Framework%20Agreement%2011%20May%202018.pdf?dl=0. The agreement is known in Chinese as 油贸信贷框架协议 or 出口信用保险合作框架. 2. This project is also known as the Salah al-Din Thermal Power Plant Completion Project. The Chinese project title is 建設的薩拉哈丁2×630兆 瓦電站工程項目 or 伊拉克薩拉哈丁電站項目 or 萨拉哈丁电站工程 or 伊拉克萨拉哈丁燃油气电站 or 萨拉哈丁燃油气电站项目. The Arabic project title isمشروع صلاح الدين البخارية ( الجالسية ) or محطة كهرباء صلاح الدين الحرارية or محطة صلاح الدين الحرارية في سامراء بطاقة ١٤٠٠ ميغاواط. 3. Several sources suggests that China CITIC Bank is the escrow account bank. However, this issue requires further investigation. 4. The export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement between China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (Sinosure) and the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq is sometimes referred to as the China-Iraq oil-for-projects (or oil-for-infrastructure) agreement. 5. The Government of Iraq has referred to a number of other projects that it intends to eventually finance through the export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement with Sinosure. These include the rehabilitation and development of Kadhimiya and Adhamiya cities, the construction of the 1GW South Baghdad Combined Cycle Power Plant (CCGT) plant, the construction of warehouses in the Southern Nasiriyah city at a cost of $350 million, as well as sewage networks, housing complexes, water desalination, schools, bridges, and other power projects. 6. The precise monetary value of the supplier’s credit for the 1260MW Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant Construction Project is unknown. However, based on the terms and conditions in the export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement between China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (Sinosure) and the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq, AidData assumes for the time being that it is equivalent to 85% of the value of the $1,329,132,251 commercial contract with CMEC ($1,129,762,413.35). 7. The September 22, 2019 financing memorandum is described by the following sources: https://www.mawazin.net/Details.aspx?jimare=66225 and http://www.ahicc.org/content.aspx?type_id=112&type_ids=93&id=8258 and https://www.dropbox.com/s/ji2fumg3lzms0x1/%E5%AE%89%E5%BE%BD%E7%9C%81%E5%9B%BD%E9%99%85%E7%BB%8F%E6%B5%8E%E5%90%88%E4%BD%9C%E5%95%86%E4%BC%9A.pdf?dl=0. 8. For evidence that the 1260MW Salah Al-Din Oil-fired Thermal Power Plant Construction Project was financed through the export credit insurance cooperation framework agreement between China Export & Credit Insurance Corporation (Sinosure) and the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq, see https://www.dropbox.com/s/g0z9s7eqsx01une/IEITI%20-%20Iraqi%20Extractive%20Industries%20Transparency%20Initiative.pdf?dl=0 and https://mop.gov.iq/documents/intl_co/International-activities/%D8%AC%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%84-3.pdf and https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/068qmf2hfqjqquu9gdqvd/2023.pdf?rlkey=ejt4x448x8wyf6jxxsyhfppmx&dl=0 9. The precise date on which the loan agreement was signed is unknown. For the time being, AidData assumes a signing date (January 1, 2020) shortly after the signing of the November 21, 2019 EPC contract. This issue warrants further investigation.